Edmonton Journal has reported:
Alberta’s government says it is not considering changes to the Human Rights Act after Premier Danielle Smith spoke about prioritizing repeal of its hate speech provision. Justice Minister Mickey Amery said the ministry would review the law to ensure it does not infringe on Albertans’ constitutionally protected freedom of speech.
Smith made the comments Saturday at an event organized by Rebel Media, a right-wing news site. Host Ezra Levant challenged her to repeal section 3 of the Alberta Human Rights Act, which prohibits discriminatory publications, displays and symbols that are likely to expose a person or class of people to hatred or contempt because of race, religion, sexual orientation or other protected grounds.
The section also explicitly protects free expression. It states that “nothing in this section shall be deemed to interfere with the free expression of opinion on any subject.” Smith told the crowd she was in “active conversation” with Amery about “prioritizing” repeal of the provision.
“We have thought that by making some of the changes that we were around woke ideology, cancel culture, DEI, we thought we were sending a message to all of our entities that we want them to focus on real issues,” Smith said, according to The Watchdog. “It turns out that maybe we need to be a bit more direct.”
Smith said she was especially concerned about the case of Benita Pedersen, a former Take Back Alberta organizer who is facing a hearing before the Alberta Human Rights Tribunal. The case concerns a flyer Pedersen distributed opposing a Pride crosswalk in Westlock.
“I’m watching the case with great dismay,” Smith told Levant. “Of course, I’m not allowed to comment on it because it’s before an independent tribunal, but we had thought that we were sending a signal and that we were appointing people to the commission where they would drop frivolous cases.” Pedersen’s hearing is scheduled to resume Dec. 8 and 9 for closing arguments.
Speaking to reporters at the legislature Tuesday afternoon, Amery said the ministry would assess the Human Rights Act. “We will continue to assess and reassess all of our legislation to make sure that it is in line with the charter, and that’s all I can say about that at this time,” he said.
The premier’s office referred a Tuesday inquiry about Smith’s comments to Amery’s office, which responded that evening. Press secretary Heather Jenkins said in an email: “Alberta’s government is committed to protecting human rights, including fundamental freedoms such as the freedom of speech. We are not contemplating any changes to the Alberta Human Rights Act.”
Alberta NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi accused Smith of “(making) things up” to satisfy Levant, whose long-standing goal has been repeal of section 3. Nenshi said Levant had pursued the issue for 30 years and described him as a former university debate partner.
“It was very clear that before he asked her that question, she had never thought about this, and now we’re spending a bunch of taxpayer time and a bunch of taxpayer money to satisfy Ezra Levant. There are bigger priorities,” Nenshi said.
The comments follow earlier criticism from Smith and Public Safety Minister Mike Ellis of Edmonton police, after the force posted on social media encouraging residents to report hate speech. Smith’s 2012 election platform as Wildrose leader had proposed repealing section 3, describing human rights tribunals as “something akin to ‘kangaroo courts’” and arguing that Criminal Code hate speech provisions were adequate.